ISSN 2336-9744 online ISSN 2337-0173 print

Ecologica Montenegrina A peer-reviewed open-access journal

Peer Review and Ethics

Editorial Screening and Peer Review Model

Manuscripts submitted to Ecologica Montenegrina (EM) are evaluated on their scientific originality, novelty, and substantive contribution to taxonomy, biogeography, and ecology. Editors and reviewers also assess the clarity of the presentation, adherence to the journal’s Guide to Authors, completeness of references, and quality of English grammar, spelling, and punctuation.

  • Initial Editorial Check: Within 10 days of submission, the Chief Editor notifies the corresponding author whether the manuscript meets the journal’s scope and formal standards to advance to external peer review.
  • Single-Blind Peer Review: Ecologica Montenegrina operates a single-blind review system. Reviewers are aware of the authors’ identities, whereas reviewers remain anonymous to the authors unless a reviewer explicitly chooses to sign their report.

Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers play an essential role in guiding editorial decisions and helping authors strengthen their work through rigorous, constructive evaluation.

  • Strict Confidentiality: Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not discuss submissions with outside parties, share files, or upload manuscript text or data into public generative AI platforms.
  • Timeliness and Competence: Invited reviewers who lack the subject expertise to evaluate a manuscript, or who cannot complete their report within the agreed timeframe, should notify the Chief Editor and decline the invitation promptly.
  • Conflicts of Interest: Reviewers must decline any assignment where a conflict of interest exists—including recent collaboration, close personal or professional ties, institutional affiliation, or direct competition with any of the authors.
  • Constructive Objectivity: Evaluations should be objective, clearly argued, and free of personal criticism. All reviewers are expected to adhere to the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

Responsibilities of the Editorial Board

  • Publication Decisions: The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority over which submitted manuscripts are accepted for publication, guided by reviewer recommendations, editorial policy, and applicable legal standards regarding libel, copyright infringement, and plagiarism.
  • Impartial Evaluation: Submissions are judged strictly on their scientific merit and relevance to the journal, without regard to the authors’ race, gender, sexual orientation, religious beliefs, ethnic origin, citizenship, or political views.
  • Handling Editorial Conflicts: Editors must recuse themselves from handling any submission in which they have a personal, financial, or collaborative conflict of interest. If the Editor-in-Chief faces a potential conflict, reviewer selection and all editorial decisions are transferred to an independent member of the Editorial Board.
  • Data Protection and Anonymity: Editors and Editorial Staff must never use unpublished data, arguments, or interpretations from a submitted manuscript for their own research without the authors’ explicit written permission. The Editorial Office also takes every precaution to protect reviewer anonymity before, during, and after the review process.

Responsibilities of Authors

Originality and Exclusive Submission

  • Authors guarantee that their manuscript represents original research that has not been published previously and is not currently under evaluation by any other journal.
  • Submitting the same manuscript concurrently to multiple journals constitutes serious ethical misconduct and results in immediate rejection. Articles already published elsewhere will not be reprinted in EM.
  • If a manuscript stems from a funded grant or expands upon a preliminary conference presentation, full details of the funding agency or conference must be disclosed in the Acknowledgments section.

Ethical Compliance and Generative AI

  • Authors are responsible for ensuring their work complies with the ethical standards established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and contains no defamatory, fraudulent, or unlawful material. Neither Ecologica Montenegrina nor its Publisher accepts legal liability for third-party compensation claims.
  • Generative AI tools cannot be credited as authors. If AI-assisted tools were used strictly to improve grammar or readability during drafting, authors must state this transparently in the Acknowledgments or Methods section. Authors remain fully accountable for the accuracy and integrity of the entire text.

Data Integrity, Permits, and Copyright

  • Reproducibility: Manuscripts must include sufficient methodological detail, voucher specimen repository numbers, and citations to allow independent verification by peers and readers. Fabricating or falsifying data is a severe ethical breach.
  • Collecting Permits: Authors bear sole responsibility for securing all legal permits required for collecting biological specimens and obtaining permission from all collaborators and data owners prior to public release.
  • Third-Party Material: Written permission from the copyright holder must be provided when reproducing previously published figures, tables, or extended text passages. Material submitted without documented permission is assumed to be the authors’ original work.

Authorship and Source Acknowledgment

  • Authorship Criteria: Co-authorship should be restricted to individuals who made substantial intellectual contributions to the study’s conception, data acquisition, analysis, or writing. Everyone who meets these criteria must be included as a co-author.
  • Acknowledgments & Changes: Technical, logistical, or linguistic assistance should be credited in the Acknowledgments. Adding, deleting, or changing the order of authors is not permitted once a manuscript has been accepted.
  • Citing Sources: All publications that shaped the research must be cited accurately. Information obtained privately through conversation, correspondence, or confidential peer review must not be used without written consent from the source.

Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest

Authors must declare any financial, institutional, or personal relationships that could be perceived to bias their findings or interpretation, alongside all sources of research funding.

Plagiarism, Misconduct Investigations, and Retractions

Plagiarism Policy and Sanctions

Plagiarism—appropriating another person’s text, data, illustrations, or ideas without proper attribution—violates both academic ethics and copyright law. This includes verbatim or near-verbatim copying, uncredited paraphrasing, reproducing figures or equations without permission, and recycling substantial portions of one’s own prior publications (self-plagiarism).

  • Pre-Publication Detection: Manuscripts exhibiting clear plagiarism are rejected immediately, and the responsible authors are barred from submitting to Ecologica Montenegrina for one year (12 months).
  • Post-Publication Detection: If plagiarism is uncovered in an already published article, the paper will be formally retracted, and the authors will be prohibited from submitting or publishing in EM for two (2) years.

Investigating Suspected Misconduct

Anyone may report suspected unethical conduct or research irregularities to the Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Staff at any time by submitting supporting evidence.

  1. Inquiry & Confidentiality: The Editor-in-Chief consults the Editorial Board to initiate an investigation. All evidence is kept strictly confidential and shared only with individuals directly involved in the review.
  2. Right of Response: The accused author(s) or reviewer(s) are always notified of the allegations and given a formal opportunity to respond before any final decision is reached.
  3. Classification of Outcomes: Confirmed breaches are categorized as either minor or major misconduct, guided by COPE flowcharts and recommendations.
    • Minor Misconduct: Handled privately with the individuals involved through educational guidance or a formal warning letter regarding misunderstandings of academic standards.
    • Major Misconduct: Resolved by the Editor-in-Chief, Editorial Board, and independent specialists where needed. Sanctions (applied individually or combined) include publishing a formal editorial notice, notifying the individual’s institution or employer, retracting the article, imposing a temporary or permanent submission ban, or referring the matter to relevant legal or professional authorities.

Retraction Procedure

Articles must be retracted when legal constraints, copyright violations, duplicate publication, fabricated data, bogus authorship, or plagiarism compromise the validity of the work. Retractions may also correct major inadvertent errors; their primary goal is to safeguard the integrity of the scientific record rather than punish authors.

In accordance with international scholarly publishing standards:

  • The online Retraction Notice links directly to the original article.
  • The online original article links directly to the Retraction Notice, clearly alerting readers to its retracted status.
  • The original PDF remains in the journal archive unaltered, except for a prominent “RETRACTED” watermark stamped across every page.